The politics of dominance and survival: Coalition politics in South Africa 1994–2018
Abstract
This article examines the factors that account for the survivability of political coalitions in South Africa. It argues that coalition survivability in South Africa is determined by the characteristics of coalition cabinets, the party distribution in the legislature that supports the cabinet, and the extent to which parties politically approach their coalition condition. The article further points out that ideological differences between political parties in coalitions, operationalised on a left-right ordering of parties, do not have a significant bearing on their duration. All the major coalitions illustrate this point. South Africa’s coalition models have primarily been comprised of minimal winning types, and the composition of all have comprised of parties with different orientations and constituencies. This demonstrates that political parties in South Africa are willing and able to rise above ideological differences to form governments, while at times these have been characterised by opportunism. The cases also reveal that political coalitions at one level often have negative implications for party relations across levels and polities. This shows that at the heart of political coalitions are the individual political leaders and the specific local context through which they approach them. Survivability is thus also a function of the ability of leaders to mobilise their constituencies in support of such coalitions.
1. Introduction
Since the dawn of the post-apartheid period, political alliance and coalition-building has become a significant feature of South Africa’s political landscape. Despite this distinctive feature, the study of political coalitions has received little attention. While most of this small literature examines the causes of alliances and coalitions, and the building of various coalitions on the eve of an election1, few have tried to explain what accounts for their varied duration, that is, their survivability, and flowing from this, their consequences for South Africa’s democratic system.
This article examines the factors that account for the survivability of political coalitions in South Africa. It will argue that two factors account for the varying durability experienced by coalition governments in South Africa: coalition characteristics and the party distribution in the legislature that supports the coalition. These factors have been in turn shaped by the characteristics of the party system.
Endnotes
1Karume, S. 2003. ‘Conceptual Understanding of Political Coalitions in South Africa: An Integration of Concepts and Practices’. Paper presented at the Electoral Institute of Southern Africa EISA Roundtable on ‘Political Party Coalitions: Strengthening Democracy through Party Coalition Building’, Cape Town; Booysen, S. 2014. ‘Causes and Impact of Party Alliances and Coalitions on The Party System and National Cohesion in South Africa’ Journal of African Elections Special Issue Understanding the Causes and Consequences of Political Party Alliances and Coalitions in Africa 13 (1) June.