Why is the emergence of coalition government so important?
Coalitions change how South Africa is governed. They can make governments more representative and accountable, but they can also bring instability that disrupts services residents depend on. How well coalitions work in municipalities affects water, electricity, refuse collection and the trust people have in local democracy.
The end of one-party dominance
For most of South Africa's democracy, one party won clear majorities almost everywhere. Coalitions change that. They give smaller parties real influence, require parties to negotiate and compromise, and make it harder for any single party to govern without scrutiny.
Where it affects people most
Municipalities deliver the services people use every day: water, sanitation, electricity, roads and refuse removal. Their councils approve budgets, appoint senior officials and oversee spending. When a coalition is stable, these decisions are made on time. When it is unstable, the effects reach residents directly:
- mayors and mayoral committees change, sometimes several times in a term
- budgets and plans are delayed or passed late
- senior posts stay vacant, or officials are replaced when the coalition changes
- motions of no confidence take up council time that could go to oversight and service delivery
Johannesburg, for example, has had several mayors since 2021. MISTRA found that half of the coalition administrations formed after the 2021 elections lasted less than about 21 months.
Instability is not the whole story
Coalitions are not always chaotic. MISTRA's 2026 Coalitions Barometer found that in more than half of the hung municipalities it studied, the party that first led the council never lost power. Coalitions that include the largest party in the council were far more stable than those that try to exclude it.
Coalitions can also bring benefits: more parties represented in decision-making, closer oversight of the executive, and agreements that make governments spell out their priorities.
Why it matters for democracy
How coalitions perform shapes how people see local democracy. If coalitions are seen to put positions ahead of residents, trust in councils and in voting may fall. If they show that parties can work together, they can strengthen accountability. That is why ACCORD tracks coalition councils, brings together councillors, officials and researchers, and shares what it learns about making coalitions work.